Comments

Valid email addresses are required to post comments. If your comment is not posted, I will send you an email with an explanation.







Tuesday, March 22, 2016

A Mission Impossible?

** Please note that there will be a bibliography available at the conclusion of the series of Blog postings.**

This is one piece of a continuing series of posts on school improvement. They advance in time and concept in book-form.
    

     It started where everything should begin - the mission of the school.

“It will not be one man going to the moon,  but an entire nation.” (Kennedy, 1961) 
JFK 

Going in Circles 
     Jean Henri Fabre, a French scientist, studied processionary caterpillars, so named because they form a single line and follow each other when they travel. Fabre conceived of an experiment to examine their behavior. (Cohen, p. 32) He placed a collection of caterpillars end to end to form a complete circle around the lip of a plate and then placed the caterpillar’s primary source of food in the middle of the plate. 
     Then he watched them. The caterpillars went around and around and around. Minutes turned into hours and hours stretched to days. Finally, after several days, the caterpillars died of exhaustion and starvation. They had circled the plate endlessly while their sustenance was inches away. They clearly had no mission other than following the caterpillar in front of them. 
     Too many schools either lack a mission or have a lengthy, ambiguous, noble sounding, dust covered statement that nobody can seem to remember. Absent a mission, these schools are comprised of valuable and well intended staff members who extend themselves in an uncoordinated manner that approximates entropy. David Osborne and Ted Gaebler, authors of Reinventing Government, provide a sad commentary that describes the plight of organizations that are not oriented around a mission: “Most public organizations are driven not by their missions, but by rules and budgets. The glue that holds public bureaucracies together, in other words, is like epoxy; it comes in two separate tubes. One holds rules, the other line items. Mix them together and you get cement.” (p. 110)     
What is a Mission? 
     A mission should be a short statement that embodies the real and actual purpose of the school. Determining the critical attribute of your organization is the most difficult step in the improvement process because there are many competing interests and needs that can mislead the true aim of the organization. Schools mean many different things to many people. It’s far too easy and tempting to merely state that the primary purpose of your school is to educate children, and leave it at that. You’re going to have to be more discriminate than that. Liken it to the doctor’s diagnosis and analysis. A careful insight will prevent the doctor from being misled by symptoms, and propel a persistent search for causes. 
     The aim of the mission, like a compass, is to assert the true North of the organization; the single driving force propelling the energy of the school staff. If the mission is expressed in terms of custodial child care or sorting and selecting rather than teaching and learning, then you’re in the wrong business.  
     Look beyond the readily apparent and publicly palatable. For instance, it would be simple and quick to assume that because we work at a school our mission would take the shape of - “graduating all students.” In Making It Happen, author Alan Weiss explained how sales of Kodak film increased significantly when Kodak comprehended what they were really selling. (Weiss, p. 27) Kodak’s advertising strategy had traditionally emphasized technical aspects of film, like emulsion rate and speed, but consumers generally purchased film for weddings, anniversaries, vacation excursions, birthdays, and the like. In other words, people were buying memories, not film. Kodak eventually shifted the thrust of their advertising campaign to commercials of backyard picnics, ball games, parties and celebrations. They began selling memories instead of film. That switch spoke volumes regarding purpose and inspiration.  
     Another example is available in merchandising. The Swiss watch industry was experiencing a 25% downturn in sales. Inexpensive and easy to read digital watches were quickly replacing analog devices. Faced with bleak prospects, an insightful manufacturer altered marketing strategies by advertising watches as jewelry or versatile accessories to clothing rather than the singular purpose of a timepiece. Swatch rode the crest of this popular wave and regained lost market share. (Peters, p. 231)   
A Commercial on Mission 
     You should be able to articulate it in the length of one breath. Anything longer will decrease the retention of the statement and thereby minimize the number of people who will remember it, communicate it, and live it. I have visited many schools and unfortunately discovered too many lengthy, erudite, and impressive sounding mission statements that are beyond the grasp and memory of those expected to enact it. Such schools, while well-intentioned, are anxiously embarking upon improvement projects with reckless abandon. 
     The most vivid examples of expressing purpose or belief with enough imagery to effectively solicit followers in a short period of time can be found in the world of advertising. (Editorial note: if I could ever reconstruct the menu of classes required of aspiring school leaders I would insist that the curriculum include a class on advertising, a class on marketing, one on political science, one on general philosophy, and more on sociology and psychology,… and less on the traditional educational administration classes!).  
     Advertisers usually have thirty seconds to ignite your senses and emotions. In that short time they attempt to point out why you have to have their product to be complete, successful, sexy,… In the advertising trade it’s referred to as the USP, or “Unique Selling Proposition.” Examples of USP are strong enough that by just giving you the phrase you can probably link it with the appropriate product: “Melts in your mouth, not your hand!” “It’s not just a job, it’s an adventure.” “It writes the first time, every time!” (Clark, p. 41) 
     Advertising executives have employed psychologists in the vital task of identifying segments of the population and accompanying values, interests, and incomes. Once they’ve classified the various sub-groups of the population they can tailor messages designed to touch those nerve endings indigenous to their group. For instance, after surveys or focus forums, advertisers determine which population subgroups are repeat customers of the goods they produce. Then they examine what television shows or print periodicals these people “graze” upon. (Clark, p. 173) That’s why we see matches like beer on shows (NASCAR and NFL football) with large audiences of members in the male, blue collar, twenty-five to fifty-five age range. These programs have distinctly different audiences than golf or tennis, for instance, which, although they appeal to far fewer viewers, connect with members of a more affluent consumer niche. As a means of conveying this point it is significant to note that Procter and Gamble “invented” the soap opera as a vehicle to hype their products. (Clark, p. 33) 
     The mission, like a clever advertisement, distinguishes you from others in your field. It emphasizes your purpose and sustains it for an indefinite period of time. It brings clarity to your parameters and scope. It reflects values, beliefs and provides guidance for behavior within the organization. It speaks to your goal or product. And finally, it is difficult to create. 
What are We all About? 
     Let’s look at what we’re all about. Effective schools researcher Larry Lezotte points to three types of missions that typically motivate schools. (Lezotte, 1988) Schools are expected to simultaneously respond to different origins of public pressure. Among these perceptions is the provision of custodial care. If you ever wonder about this listen to all of the complaints anytime your school closes for inclement weather, staff development,… parents wail about their need for sudden child care services! Another function of public education appears to be the expectation that schools render society a process of sorting and selecting among students; who goes to college and who doesn’t, who can aspire to lofty positions of leadership and influence and who should resign themselves to accepting their present station in life. Additionally, there is the altruistic function of teaching and learning, providing opportunities for all learners to realize their true potential and walk confidently into the future. 
     How is the school where you work different than any other school? There are public schools, private schools, religious schools, prep schools, home schools, charter schools, Magnet schools, not to mention the various types of schools ranging from charm schools and beauty schools to obedience schools. Check the telephone book listing for schools and you’ll find the full spectrum of offerings. But what does your school “do?” Ask around in the immediate community. Ask local realtors, they’re often the initial contact newcomers have regarding information on your school when they relocate to your area. Ask the waitress at the local coffee shop. Ask a random sampling of people on the street. What will you find? Will anyone shape their response around the basis of teaching and learning? 
     Marcus Buckingham, author of The One Thing You Need to Know, suggests that in order for a concept to evolve as the central purpose of an organization it “must apply across a wide range of situations, it must serve as a multiplier to produce exponential improvement, and it must guide action.” (p. 14) 

    * More tomorrow, including the Mission of our school *

Monday, March 21, 2016

From the Beginning

 This is one piece of a continuing series of posts on school improvement. They advance in time and concept in book-form beginning on March 21.    

     I have been asked, after posting yesterday's Blog involving practical advice on school improvement experiences gained over my career, to back up a little and start from the beginning of the transformation effort. The reader wanted a comprehensive perspective on "turning around a distressed school." If you sustain your interest through the entire series of postings that chronicle this school improvement process, I promise you  an ending with a twist that will surprise you.

     Here's the background to offer a context.

     I was thirty-four years old and just completed my tenth year as a full-time building principal. After serving as an elementary principal in a Texas school district of thirty-three elementary schools I was anxiously awaiting the outcome of an application I had submitted to become the Assistant Superintendent of Elementary Instruction for the entire school system. 

     Although I was experienced in school leadership, but remained a bit naive in the palace politics of a large school district's central office, as well as bit green regarding politics in general. I was casually classified as a Yankee by my peers, and not in a flattering fashion. The superintendent had hired me five years ago, in 1982. 

    Soon after my arrival, I discovered that the hiring process for me was unprecedented in the district. It turned out that the Director of Elementary Education had hired every other principal for the last twenty years. The past practice had left its mark on the composition of the elementary principals.  There was one Black elementary principal and a lone Latino building leader among the group of thirty-three - now joined by a Yankee.  

     There was no way that an outsider would be hired for the position I desired, but I didn't know that then. I did receive a phone call on the night of the decision. However, it was neither a congratulatory message, nor a "thanks, but no thanks" notice. Instead, I was asked by the interim Superintendent if I would be interested in serving as principal of a junior high school. Not just any junior high school, but without question the lowest performing school, at any level, in the system's forty-five schools. I was shocked by the question, and further surprised because there was no principal vacancy among the eight junior high schools. 

     It should be pointed out that this was a district that did not dismiss failing staff members. Rather, they engaged in what was generally accepted as, "the dance of the lemons" whereby individuals were moved around the vast number of schools within the district until they retired. This prevented any toxic impact on one school for a lengthy period of time. 

     The interim Superintendent simply explained that the principal was no longer working there. In fact, he and the assistant principal had been dismissed. I later learned it was reported that an eighth grader had a gun in his locker and the administrators retrieved it from his locker and sent him back to class. The teachers signed a petition that was sent to the state education agency, which prompted the state's intervention and subsequent quick action by the school district. I should also add that Texas school districts do not have unions as we know them in New York. They are represented by associations, lacking the political bargaining leverage of typical unions here.

     The offer seemed like an appealing opportunity. After all, the school could only go up! In fact, I woke up in the middle of that night and began jotting down ideas until I had a long list of prospective plans. Armed with that bit of optimism, and the perception (later proved accurate) that the central office exercised a nonchalant, benign neglect of the low socio-economic, high need schools, I was eager to start work. 

     I suspected (also later proved correct) that I could employ a wide latitude in developing programs and practices unfettered of the intervention of upper layers of bureaucracy. It was informally reported to me, off the record, that as long as there were no race riots at the school, I was free of the reaches of central office staff. Containment was the policy. Low expectations were the norm. I woke up in the middle of the night writing down ideas until I had a long list of prospective plans.

     The next day I shared the news with the few close friends I had among the group of elementary principals. Not only was I the only principal from north of Oklahoma, but only two of the thirty-three principals were near my age. My friends reacted as if I announced I had been diagnosed with cancer. There were condolences, not congratulations. Soon thereafter, I heard there were bets being placed by principals on how long I would last there - the young white Yankee in an underfunded, under-served, miserable school dominated by racial minorities and disenfranchised parents, with teachers who annually sought transfers within the district to escape. It seems the over-under was six months away, around Christmas.

     Let's start here.


Educational Alchemy 


     The World Book dictionary provides the following figurative definition of the word “alchemy.” 
     “A magical or mysterious power or process

of transforming one thing into another.”  (p. 50)  

     The term is often used to explain the process studied during the Middle-Ages that combined chemistry, magic, and philosophy in an attempt to find or prepare a substance which turned cheaper metals into gold or silver. 

     What does this have to do with school improvement?


     Many public schools find themselves involved in a similar quest for a conversion formula to transform themselves into highly effective schools where all constituent groups experience success and meet their potential. This improvement process also involves chemistry, magic, and philosophy. However, the record of performance on school transformation may not be much better than that of metal transformation. 

     Thirty-eight years as a school leader has provided a unique perspective on the issues and problems confronting schools. This career has spanned work in five different states, in environments as varied as a high minority, low socio-economic, urban junior high; a virtually all-white, affluent high school; and a rural elementary school experiencing rapidly changing demographics. Good fortune has accompanied this odyssey; being recognized as the Principal of the Year in a region of 120 different school districts in New York while serving as the leader of a school routinely awarded the highest achievement standard in the state as a High Performing/Gap Closing School; and receiving the John and Mary O’Brien Award for Educational Excellence in Texas, along with flattering recognition in varied media outlets.
  
     This Blog compilation will be organized in two separate parts. Part One focuses on the following components: 
Mission, Vision, Database, Goals, Culture, Change, and Empowerment. 

     These conceptual frames are expressed in individual chapters. Part Two offers a narrative of the transformations of two vastly different schools as a means of providing practical applications of school improvement tactics - the conversion of an urban junior high in Texas plagued by the social ills of crime and drugs into a distinguished school later described by one of its learners as “a school of hope;” and the emergence of a forlorn rural school in upstate New York that languished beneath the weight and resigned acceptance of being “good enough,” or “average.”  
*** 
     One of my hobbies is magic; hence the reference to alchemy. Magic is an intriguing subject. It also looks good on your resume, particularly when more and more school leaders are expected to routinely exercise magic on the job. I regularly employ magic in workshops on school improvement as a visual cue to introduce or reinforce key leverage points. Many people retain elements of the highlighted concept because they associate it with the effect of the trick.  
     Most of us, at one time or another, have been held spellbound by a magician. Early in my career I was curious enough, following an entertaining show, to seek additional information on magic. This interest led me to a purchase at a store specializing in magic.  
     As soon as I bought the trick the proprietor demonstrated it to me. Needless to say, I was disappointed at how easy it was to perform the sleight of hand. What at one time appeared so amazing was surprisingly easy when the process was slowed down and reduced to discrete parts that revealed the “magic.”  
     Magic and the process of school improvement share that same serendipitous feature. Once someone exhibits the proper steps the “trick” becomes much more understandable and attainable than previously imagined.

     Tomorrow marks the introduction of the process of school improvement, providing a context as well as an explanation of transformation strategies.  

Friday, March 18, 2016

Leading by Example in a School of Hope

The last few Blog entries have been opinion pieces. Today's Blog will provide practical advice borne of 38 years of school leadership experience. The main subject of the post is the effective use of positive reinforcement of desired behaviors among secondary level staff members. It was 1987, but the message of this post rings as true today as it did then.

After serving as an elementary principal for five years in an inner city school district embracing 31,000 learners in Texas, I was asked to assume leadership responsibilities of a beleaguered junior high school that was universally considered the most distressed school of the 45 schools in our school system.

I was familiar with the school because one-third of the learners at the elementary school where I worked lived in the attendance district of that junior high school and therefore continued their education there. Many factors conspired to leave the junior high school in such a the low status. The demographics (almost 90% qualified for free or reduced lunch, nineteen languages were spoken in the school, many children were being raised by a single parent or grandparents, the majority of learners comprised racial minorities in a school district that had only become integrated fifteen years earlier, in 1972) were beyond our control. But, there were several elements that deflated the school that were in our control. Chief among the areas we could influence was attitude. There was a latent sense of learned helplessness and hopelessness among learners and staff that hovered like a pall over the building. They seemed resigned to their fate. That perception was reinforced when I had walked through the building the year before as a visitor and noticed the distance that separated people and the lack of eye contact among the inhabitants of the school. The term, “dead man’s walk” would fall short of describing the atmosphere. Because it was a collective, shared despair, it was a, “dead man’s parade.”

Nonetheless, I accepted the challenge as an opportunity. The optimist in me was convinced that since the school had bottomed out it could only go up.

Without going into details at this point (I’ll refer to them in future Blog posts) the school began displaying progress. At that time, Texas public schools provided report cards at six week intervals, with the expectation that data on the rate of passing/failing would be published in local newspapers. Our figures revealed an upward trend, albeit they remained the lowest among the eight junior high school (but that would change). Much more awaited us if we were to sustain and improve upon our performance.

Nearly every and any parent of a child has had the experience of an elementary age son or daughter bringing home a paper or worksheet bearing a smiley face or sticker or encouraging remark that the teacher used to acknowledge evidence of desired effort or achievement. These incidents are commonly referred to as “refrigerator moments” because the papers typically adorn the kitchen appliance via a magnet.

Unfortunately, these same parents can attest to the belief that these refrigerator moments vanish once children begin transitioning to adulthood via entrance to junior high school, where they “need” to learn how to become adults, and adults, as we all “know” must develop intrinsic motivation because those silly smiley faces and stickers are for kids. This was clearly a commonly held opinion among staff members at our junior high. Adolescents were expected to learn for the sake of learning and not be dependent on the accolades routinely delivered by those cheerful and idealistic elementary teachers. Welcome to the "real" world teenagers.

We needed to change that perception and incorporate a new direction into our school culture. I invested much of a weekend in my office at school on a plot to precipitate such a change. It would prove to be a wise investment that eventually yielded great returns. I poured through the personnel records of EVERY staff member - not just teachers - and discovered the addresses of their parents. Then, I identified one instance of how each individual had contributed to the progress at school and made a list of the accomplishments. Admittedly, discovering a positive example was more difficult for some than others, and there were certainly missteps committed by everyone, including me, along our way. But, I focused on the positive and set our stumbles aside as learning experiences.

Next, I wrote personalized letters to the parents of every staff member that featured that one example of how their son or daughter had made our school a better learning environment and helped to nurture the dreams and sustain the hope of our learners. The letters were sent without notifying anyone on staff. The correspondence went out to many states, to parents of “children” of all ages, some in their fifties.

A few days later, individuals began stopping by my office. One by one, they would explain that they had received a phone call from a proud parent congratulating them based on a letter they received from the principal of the school. The smile on their faces as they informed me how happy their parents were hinted that their own experience could now persuade them of the potential power of positive reinforcement for learners of all ages. I even received several heartfelt letters from the parents of staff members who appreciated hearing about their “children.” 

The parent of the school’s head custodian was a bus driver in the district. The principal of another school that received passengers from the bus this man drove, called me to let me know that the bus driver came into that school’s main office and held up the letter I wrote to share with anyone in hearing range that he just got a note from his son's boss boasting of his son's excellent work!

The product of my letter writing campaign soon became evident. Bulletin boards boasted of excellent effort and achievement. Comments on report cards were more comprehensive and positive. Smiles were more noticeable and the distance between and among members of the school population decreased.

This was but one element in an improvement process that eventually catapulted the school above several others in the district regarding achievement (passing rates), attendance (daily attendance rates), attitude (sharpest decrease in discipline measures), and parent satisfaction (based on results of a survey administered district -wide). The progress resulted in a staff member recounting her experience in the transformation in a story that was published in a national magazine. But, best of all, when a television station visited the school for a story on its success and asked one of the teenage girls to describe the changes, she stated, “We have become a school of hope.”  

Thursday, March 17, 2016

Winning Minds - Not Hearts

Tuesday's edition of the New York Times featured an article that explained that the two leading candidates for the presidency are "... winning votes, but not hearts." This Blog post IS NOT about politics or my opinion on any candidate. Instead, the title of the piece attracted my attention and prompted me to think of it in educational terms. That is, how schools could also be viewed as "winning votes, but not hearts."

Here, in the state of New York, nearly all of the approximate 700 public school districts received voter approval of their annual budget on the first ballot. Some may attribute the significant success rate to recently enacted tax levy caps that have curtailed school budget growth. There may be other, specific and local factors intervening in the process, but the end result is almost unanimous approval of budgets without requiring a defeated budget to be subsequently adjusted and proposed for a second vote.

One may conclude that the budget approval of taxpayers is an indication of robust support of community members. However, if taxpayers and community members truly supported the local public school system and aligned themselves with the spirit and intent of the district, wouldn't they collectively form a mass of voters that could leverage the legislature and governor to lift the existing fiscal restraints suffocating public schools and increase the state's contribution in the form of raising state aid?

Although public schools have earned the majority of votes of taxpayers to approve annual operating expenses, I suspect a case could be made that they haven't been convincing enough to capture their hearts.

There are voters who perceive it their civic duty to support school budgets. Others may cast affirmative votes in gratitude for the people who did so when they were attending school, in some sort of pay-back. The tax levy cap may have persuaded people to vote yes, as long as the school district's budget is held in check. There are a multitude of reasons that have converged to produce exceedingly high budget approval ratings. But, if so many people believed so much in their local school district, why have they sat back and allowed the politicians to steamroll legislation that over-burdens the capacity of schools. I am not even raising the specter of the inequity in the distribution of state aid to public schools - that's another tragic story in itself. Instead, I speak of debilitating measures in accountability of teachers and schools; imposing curricula on schools prior to adequate time and money for the training of teachers necessary for successful implementation of the new curricula; expecting state tests to be administered via computers when not every school had sufficient numbers of computers for mass test administration - and some lacked the access and bandwith to meet the testing needs. I could go on, but this issue has been addressed countless times in multiple forms of media, and it is not my intent to do more than simply echo the contentions.

Instead, I want to question whether public schools are reaching and holding the hearts of those they serve as consumers (learners and their parents) and investors (taxpayers in general). Are we relying on a romanticized, tradition-based support that has passed us by in time, when public schools enjoyed a virtual monopoly on clientele? When the percentage of children attending public schools was much higher than it is now (before charter schools, and the fastest growing alternative to public schools  = home-schooling, disrupted the equation) it may have been enough to unfold the budget and await parents and relatives of the learners to come in with civic minded community members and  approve the annual budget. If this ever was true, it certainly has not been for a couple of decades, perhaps since Minnesota became the first state to allow charter schools in 1991.

According to the National Center for Educational Statistics:
1. From school year 1999–2000 to 2012–13, the number of students enrolled in public charter schools increased from 0.3 million to 2.3 million
2. In 2003 there were 1,096,000 children (2.2% of total school age children) homeschooled, in 2012 there were 1,773,000 children (3.4% of the total school age children) homeschooled.


It is no longer enough to presume that by conducting informational sessions with the local PTA and convincing them of your meaning and message, you can ensure budget approval. The numbers do not support such a strategy.

I believe that a clear obstacle to persuading the public of our purpose and value has been self-inflicted. Much like the legal profession that for many years felt that advertising their services beyond the yellow pages (remember them?) and sticking a shingle out in front of the building was unprofessional and demeaning, schools have been averse to seize the initiative (available more now with social media) to promote and brand themselves in a marketplace that has become competitive and crowded. At least lawyers have adapted (albeit, using tiresome 1-800-lawyers ads on cable television) and routinely tout their services and skills. 

By the way - yesterday's Blog post made a case for marketing (advertising, branding, surveying,...) to be included as a key component in principal preparation programs.

Parents have the opportunity to exercise choice when examining educational venues. What are public schools doing to regain market share? How are they soliciting interest and convincing parents that public schools offer the most meaningful learning experience? Finally, as a means of further drawing attention to the future survivability of public schools, here's an alarming article that appeared in today's Washington Post: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2016/03/17/the-walmartization-of-public-education/



  



Wednesday, March 16, 2016

The Wallace Foundation: Spending or Investing?

The daily email I receive from the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development (a great source of news on issues) indicated that the Wallace Foundation is seeking to leverage success in preparing principals for the challenges they face by allocating $47,000,000 toward the effort. Here's an excerpt from the ASCD article:

"Now the foundation is announcing that it will spend another $47 million during the next five years on an effort to improve principal preparation. The money will pay to redesign as many as six university training programs, each of which will be expected to partner with several school districts so that practicing superintendents and administrators have input into what aspiring principals need to learn in order to be well-prepared."

The concern I harbor, after serving as a principal for thirty-three years (at all grade configurations, in varied socio-economic environments, across the spectrum of demographics), is whether the grant will prove to be an investment (as the title of the article suggests in its wording) or whether it will merely represent another ill-fated expenditure. In an earlier Blog I sought to distinguish between "expenditures" and "investments" with the latter being a mission driven, goal supported, research based, strategic distribution of financial resources directed at a difference that makes a difference - as opposed to the former, which too often extends a traditional "more of the same" allotment of resources among competing parties, aligned with cost of living standards without respect to a changing context and uncertain future.

Simply changing titles, creating appealing acronyms (which sometimes becomes more important than the actual purpose and intent of programs in order to appease grant sources) adopting new accountability measures of principal performance, and cosmetic alterations, will not likely develop the school leaders we need to confront the challenges of an ever-changing political, social, technological, and economic interdependent world.

Einstein once claimed that, "We can't solve problems by using the same kind of thinking we used when we created them."

Here's what I would propose for any new principal preparation program.

First, erase the generic format of time guiding curricula in graduate programs developing future principal's. We live in a world where we can readily access incredible bases of knowledge which we can mine for addressing areas of deficiency regarding what we need to know about many of the issues within our schools. For example, if you have a problem with bullying in a school you are only a few clicks away from learning about a long menu of programs attendant to the issue, as well as a lengthy list of experts and practitioners who can supply assistance in crafting an appropriate and effective response for the school community you serve. Similarly, our historical commitment to the standard semester long, three or four credit course produces an off-the-rack selection. Why is it that every course magically requires/takes the same amount of seat time for accreditation? For instance, a school law class, typical in most principal preparation programs, must consume the fifteen week duration, the same as a school finance class. Coincidental, or just historical and practical? Additionally, nearly all school districts retain the services of law firms that specialize in educational and civil issues that confound school leaders. Why do we allocate essential time in a principal preparation program for areas of knowledge that we subsequently acquiesce to specialists, like lawyers? School finance may be vital for an aspiring school district superintendent, but how relevant is a fifteen week course in it for someone who hopes to lead a school? In short, we recognize and promote the value of differentiated instruction and flexible time allocations in public school classrooms, but choose to willfully ignore the same principles in our principal preparation programs.

Second, after providing a single survey course of law and finance and philosophy which (involves practitioners delivering much of the program rather than professors removed from the daily challenges of the principalship) eliminates the fifteen weeks of classes normally required in each of the subjects. I would apply the same scrutiny toward every current course requirement in principal preparation programs, paring away irrelevant or redundant classes and adjusting time frames. By the way, for full disclosure, I have served as an adjunct instructor at the graduate level and found myself surrounded by full-time professors who are swelled with a firm grasp of research and concomitant theories, but have not been challenged with incorporating what they know into a real, fluid, and dynamic environment. I am refraining from the politics of labor-management related to the growing concerns of full-time staff regarding job loss due to adjuncts - I'll leave that for others on another day.

Here are some courses/content/skills that should comprise a preparation program for principals - from someone who has served as a principal for longer than most people.

Sociology and Psychology (not just child psychology - often times the obstacles we face are adult-oriented, with staff, parents, and taxpayers) = to better understand the differences and nuances that can distinguish and divide us.

Communication = No, not the standard public speaking class, but the real thing, training in: how to go beyond 'hearing' and really 'listen'; understanding non-verbal communication; written and verbal expression, apart from the passive voice favored by the many; effective use of technology (reduce the addiction dependence on PowerPoint); how to harness and exploit the power of social media to manage meaning;

Marketing = how to identify core values and understand what is the 'unique selling proposition' of the school (you don't buy eyeglasses, you buy vision; you don't buy circus tickets, you buy thrills,.. see: A Crash Course on Marketing by David Bangs and Andi Axman. I suggest that children don't come to school for an education, they come to school to be transformed) - how to develop/burnish the school's brand in a way that distinguishes the school from any and every other school (what three adjectives do you want people to use describe the school to their friends, neighbors, acquaintances? - how to create surveys that elicit useful information - how to advertise the school - finally, these skills are crucial, given the increased competition of home schooling, charter schools, parochial and private schools.

Political Science = yes, Virginia, schools are communities within the pile of bricks and exist within larger communities outside of the schoolyard. Earning and maintaining a base of enduring followers around a common goal with shared meaning is inherently a political process. Examine techniques to navigate the political realm. One of the glaring weaknesses within educational leadership circles is our aversion to use the terms "business" and "politics" - bot of them considered dirty words! Well, check out the size of school budgets and the number of employees and there's no denying it's a business. Furthermore, schools operate in a competitive environment, against other alternatives (charter schools,...) that clearly understand and practice an awareness that they are indeed a business. Politics? Well, as resources become (and likely remain) scarce, the competition necessitates an understanding of the "roll up your sleeves" nature of obtaining services, commodities, and hope. Ignore these two elements, business and politics, at your peril. 

Leadership - I know, I know, every graduate program for principals involves instruction in leadership. But, rather than isolate ourselves around educational leaders, we can be better served by studying and meeting (if possible) positive and constructive leaders outside of education who are involved with intricate and complex, broad based issues to learn effective practices. 

Customer Relationship Management - visit and study the hospitality and/or retail sales industry to examine the best practices of customer service and sustaining relationships with consumers. We are ultimately in the business of growing people and ideas, and not confined to 'education.' How do we attract and keep customers? How do we convince taxpayers we are a worthy investment?

Resources - I would suggest that we dispense with most educational texts, which, by the way, are usually outdated (like most texts in the social sciences) and replace them with subscriptions to magazines in the field of business (i.e. Fast Company) and educational research journals. Similarly, required reading should expose future principals to Malcom Gladwell, Chip and Dan Heath, Daniel Pink, Peter Drucker, Tom Peters, Marcus Buckingham, Phillip Schlechty, Theodore Levitt, Terry Deal, Jim Collins, David Osborne and Ted Gaebler, Peter Senge,...   * I have read a significant number of business/leadership oriented books not found in the education section of the college bookstore, and compiled a repository of notes of difference-making thoughts extracted from the books to the tune of over two hundred pages of notes/quotes. This compilation has guided me like a lighthouse through the years.

Okay, that's enough for one day's attempt to solve the problems of the world. I could probably add to this, but I've run out of time at the moment. I hope I've given you something to think about.